Indian Judiciary Critique – Inside the Supreme Court Controversies
Ever wondered why some people call the Supreme Court of India a hypocrite? You’re not alone. The court makes headlines for its judgments, but it also faces serious questions about how judges are appointed, what influences their decisions, and whether the system truly serves justice. This page walks you through those hot topics, so you can form your own view.
Why the Supreme Court Faces Scrutiny
First off, the appointment process raises eyebrows. Judges are selected by a collegium of senior judges, a method many say lacks transparency. Critics argue that this closed‑door system lets personal networks dictate who climbs the bench, sparking doubts about impartiality. Have you ever looked at the list of new judges and wondered if merit was the only factor?
Next, the court’s track record on certain cases fuels the debate. Some verdicts appear to favor powerful interests, while others seem to ignore public concerns. For example, decisions on environmental clearances have drawn fire from activists who claim the court is siding with industry over citizens. These patterns make people question whether the court’s role as a check on power is being fulfilled.
Key Topics You’ll Explore
Below are the main issues you’ll find on this page. Each one is backed by real examples and easy‑to‑follow explanations.
1. Judicial Appointments and the Collegium System – We break down how judges are chosen, why the system is controversial, and what reforms are being proposed.
2. Perceived Bias in Verdicts – Look at high‑profile cases that sparked public outcry, from corporate disputes to civil liberties battles.
3. Transparency and Accountability – Learn what mechanisms exist (or don’t) for holding judges accountable, and how the public can demand more openness.
4. Impact on Everyday Citizens – See how Supreme Court decisions affect real life, whether it’s land rights, free speech, or consumer protection.
By the end of this read, you’ll have a clearer picture of why the Supreme Court gets both praise and criticism. You’ll also know where to look for reliable sources if you want to dig deeper into any of these topics.
Got thoughts on any of these points? Feel free to share your own experiences or ask questions in the comments. The goal is to keep the conversation honest, practical, and useful for anyone curious about India’s top court.
